Differences
This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.
| Next revision | Previous revision | ||
|
playground:areteee_s_rule_autism [2013/02/03 13:23] areteee created |
playground:areteee_s_rule_autism [2020/11/08 04:02] (current) |
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| === Participants === | === Participants === | ||
| - | Complainant: areteee | + | \\ |
| - | Defendant: venomthrope | + | Complainant: areteee \\ |
| + | Defendant: venomthrope\\ | ||
| + | \\ | ||
| === Events === | === Events === | ||
| On March 3rd 2013 areteee's, who is part of the [[http://dev-urandom.eu/doku.php/nations:hbe2#supporters|nazi-mongol-alliance]], may have remotely caused the death of PPA at spawn area. Without any request or formal complaint [[people:venomthrope|venomthrope]] decided to ban [[people:areteee|areteee]] saying that spawn area was neutral.\\ | On March 3rd 2013 areteee's, who is part of the [[http://dev-urandom.eu/doku.php/nations:hbe2#supporters|nazi-mongol-alliance]], may have remotely caused the death of PPA at spawn area. Without any request or formal complaint [[people:venomthrope|venomthrope]] decided to ban [[people:areteee|areteee]] saying that spawn area was neutral.\\ | ||
| Line 11: | Line 12: | ||
| 3) Even if areteee had killed PPA since they are at war it would have been legal\\ | 3) Even if areteee had killed PPA since they are at war it would have been legal\\ | ||
| 4) There is no positive rule stating that new spawn is a neutral area, venomthrope banned without a rule\\ | 4) There is no positive rule stating that new spawn is a neutral area, venomthrope banned without a rule\\ | ||
| - | 5) Even if there was such a rule, it would have had to specify what is defined as "spawn" and how large the neutral\\ "area" is, furthermore what "neutral" even means. | + | 5) Even if there was such a rule, it would have had to specify what is defined as "spawn" and how large the neutral\\ "area" is, furthermore what "neutral" even means.\\ |
| + | 6) In the end venomthrope did not once justify the ban, nor did he reply to any complaints at all.\\ | ||
| === Summary === | === Summary === | ||
| - | Venomthrope violated basic principles such as in dubio pro reo, nulla poena sine lege, the need for a formal complaint to be filled, refused to justify his ban in any way. | + | Venomthrope violated basic principles such as in [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/In_dubio_pro_reo|dubio pro reo]], [[http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nullum_crimen,_nulla_poena_sine_praevia_lege_poenali|nulla poena sine lege]], the need for a formal complaint to be filled, refused to justify his ban in any way. |
| + | === Proposed solution === | ||
| + | Since the ban has already expired, which doesnt undo the injustice done, the admin should prevent further mod abuse by\\ reprimanding venomthrope through warning, de-modding or similiar actions. \\ | ||
| === Logs1 === | === Logs1 === | ||